
Ben Handley
Whether it is a Spring Statement, Spring Budget or Spring Forecast, on 26 March the Chancellor Rachel Reeves will deliver a statement to the House of Commons. What can we expect to hear? And what do we already know is coming for the year ahead?
The Chancellor has committed to a single major fiscal event each year to give stability and certainty on upcoming tax changes.
On the day of the Spring Statement, the Office for Budget Responsibility will publish an economic and fiscal forecast, which will be followed by a statement to parliament from the Chancellor. Having repeatedly said “growth is the number one mission of this government”, we expect the Chancellor’s statement to focus on growth and the economy rather than taxes.
Given the UK’s current economic outlook, there are rumours (some rather speculative) of changes to previously announced measures. That seems unlikely on 26 March, but we cannot rule out that new anti-avoidance measures could be announced, perhaps on a ‘Tax Administration and Maintenance Day’ (TAM Day) in April.
Looking ahead, the spending review that was announced after the election last year is not due to conclude until June when the Chancellor will announce departmental budgets up to 2029/30. At the same time, a final version of the Government’s promised industrial strategy should also be published.
Stay compliant with our On Top of Tax monthly newsletter and webinar series, offering regulatory updates, key deadlines and developments in the ever-evolving tax landscape.
Provided by Nina Skero, Chief Executive - Centre for Economics and Business Research
The Chancellor faces a challenging economic landscape, but just might be able to meet the fiscal rules without announcing any major policy changes
Low growth, rising inflation, and a loosening labour market – it’s hardly the dream economic environment for any Chancellor preparing to deliver the Spring Statement. To set the scene further, let’s look at how some key economic indicators have shifted since the most recent fiscal event in October of last year.
The final quarter of 2024 saw GDP grow by a modest 0.1%, which, although low, came as somewhat of a pleasant surprise following no growth in Q3. This does at least mean that the Chancellor won’t be delivering the Spring Statement in the midst of a recession. GDP per capita, which better reflects how people are feeling about the economy, has however been declining for the past two years.
Inflation started the new year at an elevated 3.0%. The jump from 2.5% the month before is explained by sharp rises in transport costs which are being driven up by energy prices, but also one-off factors such as the addition of VAT on school fees. The upward contributions from labour-heavy sectors might suggest that some businesses were getting ahead of the higher NIC bills with price rises, but as the higher rates only come into effect in April, their impact on prices, wages, and employment will take some time to properly analyse.
On the topic of employment, the unemployment rate (4.4% in the three months to November 2024) remains relatively low, but signs of a labour market loosening are aplenty. Vacancies have been declining since the summer of 2022, and the number of paid employees has similarly been in decline. The BDO Business Trends tracker, which is produced in partnership with Cebr, just saw its employment index enter contractionary territory for the first time since November 2012.
Some commentators are pointing to robust earnings growth as a counterexample of the loosening labour market. That’s not necessarily the case, however. The recent accelerations have largely been the result of the removal of a base effect. The rising national living wage will also boost earnings growth in the coming period. In my view, this will most likely be followed by increasing unemployment as firms deal with higher labour costs. Recent business surveys have pointed to firms cutting headcount at the fastest pace since the global financial crisis (excluding the pandemic period), and the higher employer NICs will add further pressure.
Given the above somewhat gloomy state of play, you might expect the Chancellor to be tempted to offer various ‘giveaways’ in the upcoming Spring Statement. However, for several reasons, I don’t expect any major announcements.
Firstly, some of the most significant policies set out in the Budget have yet to come online, so it is an awkward time for major policy moves. Secondly, the government seems committed to having one significant fiscal event per year – the Budget – and wants to treat the Spring Statement more as an opportunity to provide an update on the latest economic forecasts. There will undoubtedly be some temptation to tinker with policies if needed, but for the sake of stability, having fewer major fiscal events is a very good idea.
Hence, if the Chancellor finds herself in a position to announce that the country is on track to meet its self-imposed fiscal rules, we might not see any major policy announcements at all. That, however, is a big if. After the Budget, the borrowing buffer stood at just under £10bn – a historically low figure which didn’t leave much room for manoeuvre. With so many inputs into the forecasts, it is impossible to have certainty on the amount of current ‘fiscal headroom’, if any. I expect that it will be a close call.
If the Chancellor has to announce that the forecasts suggest we are not on track to meet the fiscal rules, her broad options are 1) tweak the rules, 2) cut spending, and 3) increase taxes. All of these options are in play, but I see the second one, cut spending, as the most likely.
Tweaking the fiscal rules would risk losing credibility with financial markets at a particularly delicate time, given recent bond market developments. Increasing taxes is also problematic, given the very significant hikes announced just months ago and the fact that many businesses and households are grappling with the effects of low economic growth. That leaves cutting spending as the Chancellor’s least bad realistic option. As any miss to fiscal rules is likely to be modest, a relatively small adjustment in spending plans would likely suffice.
All in all, the upcoming Spring Statement promises to be an uneventful and somewhat downbeat one. The Chancellor faces a challenging economic landscape but might still just scrape by and meet the fiscal rules. While significant policy changes are unlikely, cutting spending is the most viable option if fiscal rules are not met.
After the Spring Statement, the Finance Bill 2024-25 should be enacted by the end of March. Once this is law, we will have certainty over several changes for the 2025/26 tax year. As well as publishing a raft of consultations alongside the Autumn Budget, the Government promised many further consultations would be published in 2025. We discuss the potential impact of key consultations below and await the Government’s responses to those that have already closed. Whether updates and the expected consultations are released piecemeal or en masse on a TAM Day after Easter remains to be seen.
Get in touch with our team below
Ben Handley
Caroline Harwood
Paul Falvey
Dawn Register
Jon Hickman
Ed Gibson
Christopher Rowe